Blue-ringed octopus, flamboyant cuttlefish, mimic octopus. Three animals I had never seen in twenty years of diving, on a single tank, on my first dive in the strait.
Lembeh Strait is black volcanic sand, poor visibility and rubbish on the bottom, and it holds the Macro benchmark for this entire site at a straight ten. Everything that makes it look unpromising is the reason the animals are here — no coral to hide in means camouflage, mimicry, venom and the strangest fauna on Earth.
Easy diving and difficult photography, which catches people out. The strait is shallow, sheltered and almost currentless. What it demands is buoyancy — you will spend an hour hovering centimetres above silt, and one careless fin stroke ends the dive for everyone behind you.
I surfaced from that dive elated and slightly disbelieving. Lembeh does that — it hands you, in sixty minutes, animals that most divers will only ever meet in a book. The strait has been photographed for decades and it still produces species nobody has named.
Because the honest answer is that Lembeh is a specialist destination and it does not pretend to be a beach holiday. The shoreline is muck and rock. There is only so much time anyone can spend beside a pool looking at that. If you are not a photographer, or travelling with somebody who is not, plan for it before you arrive rather than on day three.
For everyone else it is the richest small-subject diving anywhere. Hairy frogfish, sometimes two together. Coconut octopus carrying shell halves across the sand, which is documented tool use and one of the reasons octopuses are famous. Rhinopias. Harlequin shrimp. Species most divers will only ever see in a book.
If you need wide-angle to break the week, Bangka is an hour away and does exactly that. Murex runs both, and combining them is the standard advice for good reason.
Black volcanic sand, calm conditions, isolated subjects and highly trained critter-spotting guides create an image-making environment that is almost unfair.
Subjects present cleanly against dark sand with far less visual noise than a conventional reef. That means cleaner composition and more control.
It is also an excellent place to grow. The slow pace and subject density give you time to work snoots, backlighting, black backgrounds and behaviour.
Every frame here was made at Lembeh Strait in 2019, in the conditions that turned up rather than the ones I hoped for. Click any of them to open it full size.
Any frame on this page can be licensed for editorial use. Licensing terms.
March to October is when Lembeh Strait is at its best. Tap any month for what the water is actually doing.
Visibility, sea state, what is in the water and how much of it you can count on. The season turns at March and again after October.
Six I dived more than once and would plan a week around, named as the resort names them.
Muck diving at its purest
Barren and unpromising for the first ten minutes, then progressively alive the longer you hover. This is the site that teaches people what muck diving actually is.
Subject hunting along a mini-wall
A small wall rather than open sand, which gives you something to compose against. Nudibranchs, as advertised, plus most of the strait's usual cast.
Clean terrain, strange subjects
Simple uncluttered black sand hosting genuinely bizarre animals. The best site here for snoot work, because there is nothing in the background to light by accident.
Worth diving three times
High repeat value. Dive it in the morning, again in the afternoon, and again at night, and it will be three different sites.
Where the octopuses are
Sand and rubble that consistently produces coconut and wonderpus. Ask the guides where they saw one yesterday — muck diving is entirely dependent on somebody holding that map.
The antidote
An hour north for soft coral, blue water and something to point a wide lens at. Take it around day four, when muck fatigue arrives on schedule.
There is one place to stay here, so the reef score and the operator score arrive together. It is still worth separating them. The five trip axes below belong to the operation alone, and the final rating is the baseline score of the reef plus that operator's score.
Asked in the order they actually matter, answered with specifics.
Honestly, probably not, and it is the most common expensive mistake made here. The subjects are small, slow and often invisible without a guide pointing. Without a camera there is not much to do with them.
If you are travelling with a non-diver, plan for it before you book. The shoreline is muck and rock rather than beach.
Three or four, sometimes five. Profiles are shallow, so the schedule genuinely supports it, and the night diving is where a lot of the strangest animals appear.
You will get far more from the week with one. A macro lens, a focus light and a snoot if you have one. The resorts have camera rooms and the guides are used to working around a rig.
Bangka is an hour north and gives you soft coral and blue water. Murex run both, which makes the combination straightforward.
Year round. July to September is cooler and can be choppier in the strait; the critters do not go anywhere.
The right-hand column is the useful one. Misool is expensive enough that going for the wrong reason is an expensive way to find out.
Most trips begin through Manado, then a short road and boat transfer into the strait.